FDR made the appointments to the SEC on June 30, 1934. The choice of Kennedy for Chairman scandalized liberals across the country, most of whom had assumed that Landis would get the job. New Deal liberal Jerome Frank likened the appointment to "setting a wolf to guard a flock of sheep." (Seligman, 107) Journalists were ruthless: the Scripps-Howard chain tried to stop the nomination before it happened, and Wall Street critic John T. Flynn, in his New Republic column (which ran under the Brandeis phrase "Other People's Money") said, "I say it isn't true. It is impossible. It could not happen."
Ferdinand Pecora, named a Commissioner by FDR, was no happier. On July 3 he arrived in Washington and made it clear that he would be Chairman or he would leave. But Kennedy had already met with Landis and won him over. Weighing his own experience with Kennedy's, Landis realized that only the latter had the knowledge, connections, and stature to lead the agency. Landis made peace between Pecora and Kennedy, who emerged smiling for the swearing-in and picture taking.
Kennedy's personality--forceful, confident, but always with an easy smile--served him well. Journalists took to the optimistic SEC Chairman, and favorable coverage helped spread the message. Kennedy also proved his commitment to cooperation by embarking on endless rounds of conferences with exchange officials, accountants, and brokers.
Kennedy welcomed the appointment, hoping to make a name for himself and for his family. But most importantly, he believed in the mission of the SEC. The "cards have been stacked too close to those who have power," he explained, insisting that "the Federal government is the only power which can assure to the buyer that he is purchasing gold value and not gold bricks." (Wall Street Journal, July 4, 1934, and February 18, 1935) He knew that the Commission would have its limits and that it could not act as a peremptory prosecutor and judge and instinctively understood the value of regulation by disclosure, not on ideological grounds but because he believed it would work. After all, Kennedy realized, the SEC could never have the resources to police every aspect of the markets--it would have to see that the exchanges policed themselves.
Granting that, Kennedy's vision for the SEC centered around a simple objective--he would have to prove to businessmen, traders, exchange officials, and the public that the markets were better off with the SEC than without it.
George C. Mathews, James M. Landis and Joseph P. Kennedy(With permission of the John F. Kennedy Library Foundation )
Presenter(s): Doris Kearns Goodwin
with permission of the Newsfilm Library, University of South Carolina
The virtual museum and archive is copyrighted by the SEC Historical Society. The Society reserves the right to restrict access to or use of the museum by any user at any time.
Users are prohibited from sharing or downloading any material for publication or commercial purposes without written permission from the Executive Director. Requests for permission must be submitted by email and specify the material requested and for what purpose.
Material used with the Society's permission should be credited to: www.sechistorical.org.